Discover the One guy from Italy menu featuring classic Italian dishes, fresh subs, and handcrafted cocktails in Lamesa, TX. Enjoy generous portions, rave reviews, and warm service at 118 Austin Ave.
If you crave authentic Italian flavors served with generous portions and a warm atmosphere, One guy from Italy in Lamesa, TX, is a noteworthy destination. This Italian restaurant, strategically located at 118 Austin Ave, delivers a menu that proudly balances classic pizzas with creative gourmet options, alongside comforting desserts worthy of any sweet tooth.
The star of the menu is undoubtedly the 12" pizza selection. You’ll find straightforward crowd-pleasers like the 12" Cheese Pizza priced at $10.99 and customizable options like the 12" 3 Topping Pizza for $16.99, allowing for a personalized experience. However, where this place truly shines is in their gourmet pizzas. They offer bold, inventive creations such as the Baked Ziti Pizza, a rich layering of baked ziti flavors on a crispy crust, priced at $21.75, and the Chicken Bacon Alfredo at $19.99, marrying creamy Alfredo sauce with tender chicken and smoky bacon perfectly. The Spinach "Florentine" Pizza, with steamed spinach, ricotta, and tomato-basil sauce, offers a fresh yet savory relief from more traditional toppings, showcasing their range and depth in flavor.
For fans of Italian deli meats, the October The Italian Guy pizza, featuring salami, pepperoni, ham, a tangy balsamic base, and pepperoncinis, serves a powerful punch of classic charcuterie with a twist — all for under $15. The creativity behind combining these toppings highlights the restaurant’s commitment to authentic and bold taste experiences.
Desserts are simple yet satisfyingly authentic. The Cheesecake and Cannoli, each around $5, maintain a traditional edge, while the Chocolate Cake at $6.99 rounds out the meal with a rich finish.
One cannot review the dining experience here without mentioning the consistently praised service. Most guests highlight the attentive and friendly waitstaff, who ensure each visit feels welcoming, as seen in glowing comments from customers like MJ B., who noted the clean, spacious environment and delightful hospitality. Even though one customer pointed out an isolated issue with a less agreeable hostess, the majority emphasize the staff’s professionalism and customer focus, which contribute substantially to the overall ambiance.
The portions are generous, with multiple reviewers noting leftovers as a bonus rather than a drawback. Dishes such as fried raviolis and calamari emerge as great starters and crowd favorites, recommended alongside their pizzas. The shrimp, noted as exceptionally large and fresh, adds an upscale touch to the menu, reflecting the kitchen’s care in ingredient selection.
Overall, One guy from Italy offers a compelling Italian dining experience in Lamesa — a blend of classic flavors and inventive twists, great ambiance, and service that makes you feel valued. Whether it’s a family gathering or a casual pizza night, this place deserves a spot on your list.
